Results

What changed because a panel reviewed the plan — manually curated, with every finding linked to the deliberation that produced it.

Conditional GO
Curated scenario
Session result

A moderator-found index collision turned a live patch into a quiesced cutover.

Landed invariant

Old and new credit writers are never eligible together; canonical uniqueness is installed and proven before intake reopens.

PSP Webhook Double Credit
GPTGrokMuse
$1.35·1 contradiction caught after convergence
GO1 open decision
Curated scenario
Session result

Three GOs — and one decision the panel refused to make for you.

Ratified rule

A PASS_AFTER_RETRY is always YELLOW and never improves first-attempt metrics; every test must maintain >=99% first-attempt passes over rolling 200; the allowlist expires after 14 days with an owned issue.

Flaky CI Fix Sprint
GPTGrokMuse
$1.27·1 measurement trap the fix would have hidden
GO 2-1
Curated scenario
Session result

The fix survived its own breaking; the split is over release conditions.

Landed invariant

Every path that can create another job execution — including crash recovery — passes one retry-policy function with a hard attempt cap; customer-facing bad_input requires proven byte identity, never metadata.

Poison Pill Job Retries
GPTGrokMuse
$0.93·1 structural hole found in the panel's own fix — and patched in-session
Conditional GO
Curated scenario
Session result

The plan survived scrutiny; one harmful probe died and four safeguards landed.

Validated plan

Durable pre-attempt state, per-encounter isolation, actionable clinician status, and fenced publication ship together; active probes do not.

LLM Note Worker Hang
GPTGrokMuse
$1.00·Core plan held · 1 option killed · 4 safeguards added
GO — Canary
Curated scenario
Session result

Loop order was deciding money; the fix ships as a flagged canary.

Landed invariant

Discount selection and application are two phases bound by a quote-ID + dual-revision CAS — a checkout can never apply a price the customer wasn't shown.

Promotion Stacking Correctness
GPTGrokMuse
$1.00·5 defects found in the room's own design